Introduction

What is LDD Pro

LEGO Digital Designer Pro (LDD Pro) is LEGO’s in-house 3D building software. It has two modes: Build mode, for creating LEGO sets from scratch or from a bill of materials, and Building Instructions mode, for turning a finished virtual model into step-by-step instructions.

Its users range from model and instruction designers to LEGO Games, LEGO Movies and LEGOLAND Parks.

Screenshot of LEGO Digital Designer

Replacing an outdated system

Diagram of the LDD Pro ecosystem

In 2020, LEGO relied on a patchwork of department-owned tools with no central platform for digital assets. To ship products faster, it started cleaning up that workflow, beginning with how digital sets are made.

The main tool was Easy Builder Tool (EBT), a hard-to-use Maya plugin that required Autodesk Maya licenses.

Changing habits

Model design analysis

Part of the work was persuading users that LDD Pro could replace their current way of working.

The objective

LEGO headquarters being built in Denmark

LEGO wanted better building instructions to help reduce the high dropout rate among new customers.

LEGO office

Modernizing how instructions are designed was a way to get back into innovation, recover lost business and reach more children.

The process

Model Orientation tool

Users complained that building at an angle was hard and took too many mouse miles. Below, getting the white beam at 90 degrees to the green one takes planning or luck.

Many bricks have irregular shapes, so reorienting the model to a selected brick was not enough. With the two developers on my squad, I used the connectivity fields every brick has instead: the tool reorients the scene to a chosen field.

Connectivity fields shown in the LDD Pro developer mode

Model Orientation tool design

My first designs had many modes and options, partly for edge cases like angled beams that a 90 degree snap would never straighten.

Angled red beam that a 90 degree snap cannot straighten

Once users could pick individual connectivity fields, those options became redundant. The result was simple and fit the workflow of the existing tools.

Timeline and Outliner

Building instructions group minor steps into sub-builds, like the one in the yellow cutout below. The old UI made them hard to spot, which caused confusion and errors.

Printed building instructions with a sub-build highlighted

Building Instructions mode in LDD Pro

The timeline showed steps in order, but was hard to link to the outliner, where sub-builds appear above the step where they are placed.

Ableton Live arrangement view

Inspired by the color cues in Ableton Live, I made mockups that used color to show structure in both views.

Camera fittings concept artboard

Camera fitting ranges outliner concept

I started in the outliner to get buy-in, then moved to the timeline, where each sub-build got its own color and clear start and end points.

Fitting ranges timeline concept

I then wrote a table of interaction rules for how the blocks respond to user input.

Camera fitting ranges interaction design table

Fitting ranges blocks interaction design illustration

Users could now skim the structure of an instructions file without expanding items in the outliner. Here is the final result in the app.

Camera fitting ranges in the working application

Click Stick snapping

I added an option to the Click Stick tool that lets users choose how strictly bricks snap while modelling.

Year of the Monkey LEGO model

In this model, the hardest part was not the monkey but the green plants on the base.

Year of the Monkey model showing the Click Stick problem

Placing a plant at 45 degrees meant using the physics-based Connection tool, because the building rules snapped rotated bricks back to 90 degrees.

Click Stick tool affect option mockup

The fix let users choose what the rules affect. Position and rotation works exactly as before, so existing habits don’t break. Position only snaps the brick without changing its rotation. This cut a very common task from minutes to seconds.

Rigid Body tool

I designed a “glue” tool to make physics tools like Hinge Align and the Connection tool more predictable.

In an internal usability survey, the top complaint was that tools made unpredictable changes to the model.

Survey results about tools making unpredictable changes

In this typical case, keeping the two red beams at 90 degrees while closing the loop was almost impossible, because the tool affected every brick.

Canonical example of why the glue tool is needed

The developer build had a debug view that colored each rigid body differently. I proposed exposing it to users: bricks in the same color are glued together and move as one.

Rigid body glue tool view

I first mocked up the glue view inside each physics tool.

Rigid body edit mode workflow

After many discussions, I made it a dedicated tool instead.

Glue tool Mural board

Users only need to ask: are these two bodies the same color? Physics tools became more predictable and faster, since fewer rigid bodies are simulated.

Design system and UI

LDD Pro’s interface was dated, so I made a concept to show the product team what it could look like.

LDD Pro user interface

Concept design of a modernized LDD Pro

Tool options move to the lower left of the viewport, like in Blender, where they are always in the same place and can be collapsed.

Control options for tools

The toolbar takes less space while showing names next to icons.

Expanded toolbar

The brick palette uses a split layout to show categories and contents at once, and the Model Window packs more information into less space to leave room for the viewport.

Old and new brick palette

Old and new Model Window

From using Autodesk Alias, I saw how fast experienced users work with pie menus. In LDD Pro, they could trigger menu commands with fewer mouse miles.

Marking menus concept

Splash screen

Old LDD Pro splash screen

New LDD Pro splash screen

Other improvements

Results

SKU adoption

The share of SKUs made in LDD Pro went from 38% to 69% between the end of Q1 and the end of Q2 2021, with a target of all SKUs by the end of Q3 2021.

Faster model building

A senior LEGO model designer who has built hundreds of BrickHeadz characters recorded himself building the same one in EBT and in LDD Pro as fast as he could. In EBT, a fully priced model took over 13 minutes. In LDD Pro, it took under 5, a reduction of 61.5%.

This does not halve design lead time, since most creative work happens away from the screen. But with up to 24 weeks per product and one day a week of digital building, halving building time saves about 2.5 weeks.

IP partner reviews

The same designer built a Harry Potter concept model in LDD Pro, taking it through BOM lock and M-Phase in LDD Pro for the first time.

User feedback

Message from a LEGO model designer

Hi team, I haven’t had the chance to use LDD Pro for a few weeks, but I’m using it a lot today and I must say, with the recent improvements that have been made, it is really turning out to be a great tool. Well done, you should be proud!

— Model designer, LEGO

Color Surface efficiency

Color Surface efficiency improvements

Flex tool

Previously, instruction designers requested flex variants from another team, where an artist took about 4 hours. With the improved tool, I made a better-looking layout in 36 minutes on my first try: 6.5 times faster, without outside help.

Flex layout before the improvement, made in 4 hours

Flex layout after the improvement, made in 36 minutes